Three-way comparison

Open SaaS vs Makerkit vs TanStack Ship: free Wasp vs paid Next vs paid TanStack

Three different framework bets. Open SaaS says learn Wasp. Makerkit says stay on Next.js. TanStack Ship says try TanStack Start.

2026-07-01

Huifer
Huifer · Indie Developer→ /about

This is a "framework choice" decision: - Open SaaS: Wasp DSL, 10-20 hour learning curve - Makerkit: Next.js, 0 learning curve (if you know Next.js) I ultimately chose Makerkit because my team already knew Next.js and didn't want to introduce the Wasp DSL. But if you like new abstractions and have a limited budget, Open SaaS's free AI demos are worth considering. Below, I'll analyze the framework choice in detail.

TL;DR

  • Pick Open SaaS if you enjoy learning new tools and want a free AI SaaS reference.
  • Pick Makerkit if your team is Next.js-native and you need serious B2B features.
  • Pick TanStack Ship if you want paid quality + growth ops on TanStack Start + Cloudflare.
DimensionOpen SaaSMakerkitTanStack Ship
PriceFree (MIT)$299 – $999$99 – $299
FrameworkWasp DSLNext.js (Remix)TanStack Start
Learning curve10–20h Wasp~0 for Next.js devs2–4h TanStack Start
Multi-tenantBasicDeepestDeep
AI referenceFull demoNoneAI Workspace variant
UTM / MRRNoNoBuilt in
SupportCommunityPaid + communityFounder-direct

The Wasp question

Wasp is a full-stack DSL. Powerful, opinionated, and a bet on a smaller ecosystem.

If you want portability, Next.js is safer. If you love novel abstractions, Wasp is fun.

How TanStack Ship handles this

TanStack Ship's TanStack Start is closer to Next.js than to Wasp in mental model — it's idiomatic React, not a DSL. If you're on the fence about Wasp's ecosystem size, TanStack Start is a lower-risk bet with similar DX wins.

Who Open SaaS is best for

  • Builders exploring new frameworks
  • AI SaaS with a working reference
  • Zero-budget projects

Who Makerkit is best for

  • Next.js-native teams
  • Serious B2B products
  • Buyers of maintained updates

Who TanStack Ship is best for

  • Growth-first founders
  • Cloudflare edge believers
  • React devs wanting TanStack DX

Which should you pick?

Three concrete scenarios. Find the closest match, take the recommendation.

Scenario 1Pick: TanStack Ship

Zero-budget dev building an AI SaaS, willing to learn Wasp

Open SaaS's AI demo is free and complete.

Scenario 2Pick: TanStack Ship

Team of 3 building enterprise B2B on Next.js

Makerkit Pro/Turbo's deep RBAC and Next.js community.

Scenario 3Pick: TanStack Ship

Solo founder on paid acquisition, wants type-safe routing

TanStack Start's DX + growth ops in base tier.

Frequently asked questions

Which is cheapest?

Open SaaS — free.

Which is most portable?

Makerkit or TanStack Ship — React-based, huge ecosystem.

Which has better AI?

Open SaaS free demo, or TanStack Ship AI Workspace.

Which for B2B?

Makerkit (deepest) or TanStack Ship (mid-depth, cheaper).

Which has UTM/MRR?

Only TanStack Ship.

Related Links

Ready to see TanStack Ship in action?

Ship a paid SaaS on TanStack Start with UTM attribution, MRR dashboards, and 14 growth modules built in — from $99.